
Ranking the top 9 Everton best players who made football history
Everton FC, one of the oldest and most prestigious clubs in the Premier League, has produced many great players over its century-long history. Each generation of players at the club has had their share of history-making players, leaving an indelible mark on the hearts of fans. In this article, Premiumsoccertips.net will take a look back at the list of Everton best players, from attacking legends like Wayne Rooney and Duncan Ferguson, to defensive stars like Seamus Coleman and Leighton Baines.
Top 9 Everton best players of all time
Everton has produced many football legends, and below are the Top 9 Everton best players who have contributed to the glorious history of the Merseyside team.
Top 9: Jordan Pickford
Jordan Pickford joined Everton in 2017 and immediately became the club’s first-choice goalkeeper. His calmness under pressure has helped Everton through many difficult seasons, playing a crucial role in securing the club’s Premier League status during turbulent times. With excellent reflexes, Pickford is one of the top goalkeepers in the Premier League, although he has made occasional unforced errors. However, his ability to make key saves, particularly in tough matches, has made him a fan favorite at Goodison Park.

Pickford’s shot-stopping ability, especially his saves from long-range shots and set-pieces, has helped him build a special relationship with Everton fans. With consistent performances and some incredible saves, the English goalkeeper has become a solid foundation in goal, providing the team with confidence and peace of mind for many seasons.
Top 8. Wayne Rooney
Wayne Rooney, one of the most talented players in English football history, had two spells at Everton during his career. Particularly in his first stint, Rooney scored his first professional goal against Arsenal at just 16 years old, becoming a symbol of the club from an early age. After moving to Manchester United, where he became a legend, Rooney maintained a special bond with Everton, and his return in 2017 was an emotional moment in his career. With his impressive goal-scoring ability and innate talent, Rooney was always a standout star wherever he played.

However, Rooney’s time at Everton was brief, with the club only really having him during the early and late stages of his career. Nonetheless, he left a significant mark at Goodison Park, especially during the tough seasons following his return in 2017, where he played a leadership role and provided valuable experience to the team. Rooney’s goals, combined with his technique and leadership, helped Everton maintain stability in recent years.
Top 7: Leon Osman
Leon Osman was a loyal and dedicated player throughout his career at Everton, making over 350 appearances in major competitions. While not known for dazzling dribbles or long-range shots, Osman was always behind Everton’s success due to his calmness and ability to control the pace of the game. He was the type of player who never gave up, working tirelessly but effectively to help the team maintain stability in any situation. Osman’s relentless dedication helped him become one of the most beloved players at Goodison Park.

Not the brightest star, Osman always showed up at the right moments to control the game, being a solid pillar for his teammates. He helped Everton maintain balance and assurance in midfield, particularly under David Moyes. With his finesse and excellent ball distribution, Osman proved to be one of the club’s most important players in history, even if not always in the spotlight like other stars.
Top 6: Tim Cahill
Tim Cahill is one of Everton’s fan favorites due to his relentless fighting spirit and impressive goal-scoring ability, despite not having ideal height. Cahill scored 56 goals for Everton during his eight years at the club, including 22 headers an impressive feat for a player of his stature. He was known for appearing at the right moments and scoring decisive goals in important matches, particularly against Liverpool. Cahill’s goals, combined with his strong character, helped him become an Everton legend.

Cahill was not only an outstanding player but also the emotional leader of the team, always encouraging his teammates to push through challenges. He always gave his all for Everton, never backing down despite facing huge challenges. Cahill’s fighting spirit and dedication made him one of the club’s living legends, providing many thrilling moments for fans.
Consult bookmaker to choose your favorite players and make more accurate predictions for each match.
Top 5: Leighton Baines
Leighton Baines is one of the best left-backs in Premier League history, known for his attacking prowess and excellent free-kick technique. Baines played a vital role in Everton’s attacking play with his decisive passes and ability to score from set-pieces. He scored 26 goals from 29 penalty kicks, an impressive record for a defender. Baines always played with composure and technical skill, contributing to dangerous attacks from the left flank.

Although he earned only 30 caps for the England national team, Baines was a key figure for Everton for many years. With solid defensive abilities and sharp attacking contributions, he helped the club maintain stability at both ends of the pitch. Baines’ contributions left a deep mark on Everton fans, and he is regarded as one of the best left-backs in Premier League history.
Top 4: Duncan Ferguson
Duncan Ferguson is one of the greatest forwards in Everton’s history, known for his physical style of play and relentless fighting spirit. Ferguson is the epitome of a true “number 9,” scoring over 60 goals in his Premier League career. Although not the most technically gifted, Ferguson was always a major threat in the opposition’s penalty area with his aerial ability and decisive finishing. He became an irreplaceable icon at Goodison Park, with his powerful attacks and never-say-die mentality.

Ferguson was not just a great player but also a symbol of loyalty and resilience. He always fought for the blue jersey of Everton, and his spirit has made him a legend beloved by both Everton fans and football lovers in general. Despite some controversies during his career, Ferguson remains one of the greatest players in the club’s history.
Top 3: Dave Watson
Dave Watson is the legendary captain of Everton, leading the club to victory in the 1995 FA Cup, the only FA Cup win for the club since the 1980s. Watson was not only known for his strong play and leadership skills but also for his tireless commitment. He inspired his teammates, never stopping fighting for the blue jersey, even during the club’s toughest times.

Throughout his career, Watson became a pillar of the team, showing bravery and dedication. His career is a testament to Everton’s core values: loyalty, strength, and never giving up. Watson dedicated his entire career to fighting for the club and left behind a strong legacy for future generations of players.
Top 2: Seamus Coleman
Seamus Coleman is a symbol of loyalty and perseverance at Everton, having been with the club since 2009. Although not the most technically gifted player, Coleman has always played with an unmatched fighting spirit, constantly improving himself and earning the trust of every manager. He became Everton’s captain at 36 and has led the team through many ups and downs. Coleman is an excellent right-back, known for his solid defending and dangerous attacking runs down the right flank.

Coleman’s journey from a relatively unknown player to one of the top right-backs in the Premier League is a testament to his dedication. His commitment and love for the club have made him a living legend at Everton, and fans hold him in deep admiration. Coleman’s precise crosses, fierce defending, and leadership have helped Everton maintain its stature over the years.
Top 1: Tim Cahill
Tim Cahill is one of the best players in Everton’s history, thanks to his impressive goal-scoring ability, despite not having ideal height. With 56 goals in eight years, Cahill is among the club’s top goal-scorers. He was particularly known for his decisive headers, despite not being a tall player, and is one of the best midfield goal-scorers in Premier League history. Cahill’s goals, especially in important matches, helped Everton secure memorable victories.

Not just a prolific goal-scorer, Cahill was an inspiration to his teammates due to his determined attitude and unwavering loyalty to the club. He served as an ideal role model for future generations of players and will undoubtedly remain a legend of Everton for years to come.
To Wrap It Up
Each player on this list of Everton best players has contributed to a proud chapter in Everton’s history, from the peak moments to the quiet, but equally important, achievements. They are not only prominent names on the pitch, but also living symbols, demonstrating fighting spirit and absolute loyalty to the club. Regardless of the period, they are the ones who have brought pride to the fans, making Everton famous. All of their contributions will be remembered forever, a solid legacy that future generations will always admire and follow.